Dominguez has narrowly escaped facing adult charges that would have robbed him of chances for rehabilitation and increased his likelihood of committing further crimes. Treating young offenders in a system meant for adults endangers young criminals, fails to deter youths from further criminal action and is racist. Juvenile and adult justice systems should implement a policy of segregated incarceration to avoid perpetuating injustice.
Should Juvenile Criminals be tried as Adults? Life is precious and we live it only once, however, what we do with it is to our own discretion. It is a shame that many people at young ages decide to live a life of misdeeds and become what we call juvenile criminals, but, every action has a consequence and to deal with these unlawful adolescent we have the Juvenile Justice Department.
The juvenile justice system is a network of agencies that deal with juveniles whose conduct has come in conflict with the law. These agencies include police, prosecutor, detention, court, probation, and the Department of Juvenile Corrections. However, when young offenders commit a series of crimes, constantly being in trouble with the law, they are waivered into Adult court where they will be subject to any punishment available.
In some cases they are waivered into the adult system automatically such as in homicide cases. Being tried as adults exposes these juveniles to state penitentiaries and sentences up to life in prison without parole and even execution. But is this truly effective? Do these juveniles have the capacity to truly understand the crimes they are committing?
Is there an age limit for introducing these juveniles into the adult justice system? Is there something or someone behind the acts of these young offenders? These questions leave us wondering if this notion really is effective or is there a better way of handling young criminals.
We have seen today in society how crime rates have been sky rocketing and how statistics prove that the majority of the crimes are being done by minors.
I believe that when you look into the background of these young delinquents most of them come disproportionately from impoverished single parents homes located in disinvested neighborhoods and have high rates of learning disabilities, mental health, and substance abuse problems and with help of the juvenile justice system they can make a huge turn into a successful transition in to adulthood.
Their ages range from twenty and under, most are younger than fifteen years. He also discusses how many advocates and academics argue that juveniles are not being given enough of a chance to turn their lives around after committing minor offenses.
In agreement with Stier, I consider that juveniles have greater possibility than adults to make a change in their lives with the right help, counseling and rehabilitation. Stier also states; there is new brain research showing that the full development of the frontal lobe, where rational judgments are made, does not occur until the early to mid 20s.
Lexcen, Thomas Grisso, and Laurence Steinberg article: This being they are not fully mentally stable and developed in difference with adults who have full capacity and judgment to their actions this discarding criminal with mental incapacities.
They also argue the fact that in most states they do not specifically analyze if a minor is competent to proceed in criminal court as a requirement for judicial waiver unless he or she presents a mental disorder.
Not all courts simple waiver them into adult trials some due follow a criteria in order to transfer a juvenile into criminal court. Juvenile delinquents tried as adults have to assume the same consequences as any other criminal and are subjected to state penitentiaries with inmates much older and who have probably committed crimes far more devious then they could ever have.
These minors range from the ages of nine to twenty depending on the crime committed or on how many times they are prosecuted and believe to be unchangeable. They are exposed to the harsh cruelty of penitentiary life where most are raped, beaten, and subjected to any abuse seen and known in these prisons no matter their age, mental and emotional state.
If scientists and psychologist who study the human brain and development determine they are not capable of full capacity and maturity and their brains are not fully developed as to rational judgment; what is causing them to do such horrendous crimes such as murder?
If someone is raised in a violent environment where they physically or visually experience cruelty, they are more likely to do the same. We have to realize that the people around us influence or actions and our change of character.
Most young criminals are also controlled by organizations run by unlawful adults who promise them a way out of poverty and misery when they truly are shortening their lives. The different situations are endless but I believe they should not be implemented into adult penitentiaries, especially those younger than eighteen.
They should be placed with those their age group even though their sentencing can be that of an adult. However many disagree and they believe if these young offenders are capable of committing a crime like murder, no matter their maturity, they should be tried as adults.
We are not born devious and malicious; people are molded into who they become.Juveniles should not be tried as adults they are still physically growing and mentally maturing during their teen years.
The transition from childhood to adulthood is often very difficult for some teens. The Cons of Juveniles Being Tried As Adults. 1. A juvenile offender may not have a clear understanding of the crime they committed. A child’s brain is not fully developed and their sense of right and wrong is much different than an adult’s.
List of Cons of Juveniles Being Tried as Adults. 1. Minors will be put at risk Similar to the concern of the lawyer and families of the Wisconsin girls, young offenders are at risk of being sent to an adult correctional facility if they are tried in an adult court.
Should juveniles be tried as adults essays Baron alderson stated before a given as adults don't think that you will be tried as. Essentially, should juveniles being tried and empower you should be tried as adults. Staff working on human services includes the Children and Families Program in Denver and the human services federal affairs staff in Washington, D.C.
We provide services to legislators and staff working to improve state policies affecting children and their families. Children with mental health needs sometimes enter a juvenile juveniles from adults in important ways that make them less able to assist in their defense or to make important decisions as part of the process.
This Mental Health Needs of Juvenile Offenders.